Justice overruled in the UAE?
Wednesday 04 August, 2010
The Federal Supreme Court of the UAE has ruled in a recent case that the Ministry of Justice has the power to overturn any Court ruling which it deems to be “improper”.
According to Justice Amin Ahmed al Hajeri of the Federal Supreme Court, the Attorney General has the power to overturn any final Court decision “if he considers that the verdict is based on a mistake in implementing or interpreting the law”. He may also do this upon written request from the Minister of Justice and Islamic Affairs. Whilst the Attorney General does not have the power to issue a verdict of his own, this ruling effectively gives him (and the Ministry of Justice as a whole) the power of veto or the ability to insist that any case is retried.
In the June 2010 ruling in question, an Al Ain businessman sued two of his partners whom he claimed owed him money. The Court of First Instance apparently ruled that both partners were liable but, following an appeal, the Court of Appeal instead ruled that only one partner had to pay. The partner who was ordered to pay appealed to the Federal Supreme Court who refused to hear his case. He then applied to the Ministry of Justice for a re-trial. The Ministry agreed and wrote to the Supreme Court requesting a new trial on the basis that the verdict of the Court of Appeal had been based on an incorrect assumption. The Supreme Court granted the request for a re-trial.
It is of some concern that the Ministry of Justice was able to intervene in this way in the due process of the Courts and Mohammed Abdullah Al Zaabi of the Federal National Council has already criticised the Ministry of Justice for interference in this respect. The Federal National Council (“FNC”) was established in 2005 for the purpose of assisting the government in the implementation of its goal to enhance political toleration and develop a legislative process in a tolerant and consistent environment. The FNC’s principal power therefore lies in its right to question government Ministers about their actions.
Since the UAE does not really operate a system of precedent with regard to Court judgments, there is a question mark as to how this ruling will affect future cases, if at all. Nevertheless, it is of concern and raises further uncertainty in an already uncertain system. We will monitor the situation and report on this again should there be further developments.
bob.deering@incelaw.com
alexandra.bailey@incelaw.com
Date: Wednesday 23 - Thursday 24 May, 2012
Location: One Drummond Gate, London
Ince & Co partner Chris Kidd is speaking on “Managing conflicts and disputes”. He is also chairing and moderating some sessions.
Date: Wednesday 23 - Friday 25 May, 2012
Location: London
Ince & Co partner Fionna Gavin will be speaking during the morning of the third day on “Tanker Charterparties - time and voyage”. Which will cover the differences in, and justifications for, tanker chartering.
Date: Thursday 24 May, 2012
Location: London
Ince & Co partner Faz Peermohamed will be speaking during day one of the conference on “Shipping: The Titanic, Prestige, Costa & Pirates”.
Date: Tuesday 29 - Wednesday 30 May, 2012
Location: Cowes, English Channel, Isle of Wight, Solent
Ince & Co will be taking part in the Lutine Lineslip Regatta, a Lloyds Yacht Club Event for the Insurance Industry, in May 2012.
Date: Tuesday 29 May, 2012
Location: British Consulate, Hong Kong
Ince & Co partner Denys Hickey will be speaking at the forum on “Contractual challenges in the LNG distribution supply chain”. The session will cover balancing long term security and flexibility in contracts and identifying and mitigating risks in LNG supply contracts.